One Nation, Two Federalisms: Rediscovering the Origins of Australian Federal Political Ideas

File Size Format
24568.pdf 511Kb Adobe PDF View
Title One Nation, Two Federalisms: Rediscovering the Origins of Australian Federal Political Ideas
Author Brown, Alexander Jonathan
Publication Title Proceedings: Annual Conference of the Australasian Political Studies Association
Editor Haward, M.
Year Published 2003
Place of publication Hobart
Publisher Australasian Political Studies Association (APSA)
Abstract Federalism is usually described in Australian political science and history as representing one, coherent amalgam of ideas, first enunciated in Australia in the 1840s-1850s. At the same time, Australia experiences ongoing debate about the wisdom and applicability of federal ideas in their present geographic form, suggesting schisms not simply within Australian politics but within federalism itself, sufficiently deep to require a reconsideration of current federalist orthodoxy. This paper seeks to reopen debate about the origins and diversity of federal ideas in Australia by squarely attacking orthodox assumptions regarding their historical starting point and subsequent hegemonic character. The territorial separation of Van Diemen's Land from New South Wales in 1823-1825, the foundation of Port Phillip in 1835-1841 and other events reflected a significantly earlier reception of federal thought into Australia than previously described. Sometimes hinted at, but hitherto not analysed, this first federalism had a previously unappreciated level of support in British colonial policy and drew directly on Benjamin Franklin's 'commonwealth for increase' ideas of territorial change booming in America. While these discoveries entrench notions of the suitability of federalism in Australia, this original Australian federalism was quite different to the 'classic' or compact theory of federalism dominating Sydney and London ideas of the 1840s-1850s, the 1890s and the bulk of 20th century scholarship. In fact Australian political thought contains not one, but at least two quite distinguishable and sometimes conflicting ideas of federalism. By recognising Australia's first, more decentralist version of federal principle, the paper emphasises Australia's uniqueness in global history, exposes as a myth the assumption that Australian federalism grew purely out of a landscape of autonomous Australian colonial governments, and reveals that most colonies were formed in circumstances which presumed their long-term role as subnational units in a continental federation. This reappraisal of federalism's roots helps explain longstanding dissent over the territorial basis of Australian constitutionalism and aids the potential for a new reconciliation of federalism and regionalism in Australian political thought.
Peer Reviewed Yes
Published Yes
Publisher URI http://www.auspsa.org.au/
Copyright Statement Copyright 2003 Australasian Political Studies Association (APSA). This is the author-manuscript version of this paper. Reproduced in accordance with the copyright policy of the publisher.
Conference name Australasian Political Studies Association Conference 2003
Location Hobart
Date From 2003-09-29
Date To 2003-10-01
URI http://hdl.handle.net/10072/1652
Date Accessioned 2004-04-02
Date Available 2007-12-21T07:12:43Z
Language en_AU
Research Centre Socio-Legal Research Centre; Centre for Governance and Public Policy
Faculty Faculty of Arts
Subject Constitutionalism and Constitutional Law
Publication Type Conference Publications (Full Written Paper - Refereed)
Publication Type Code e1

Brief Record

Griffith University copyright notice