Doctors Are More Dangerous Than Gun Owners: A Rejoinder to Error Counting

There are no files associated with this record.

Title Doctors Are More Dangerous Than Gun Owners: A Rejoinder to Error Counting
Author Dekker, Sidney
Journal Name Human Factors
Year Published 2007
Place of publication United States
Publisher Sage
Abstract Objective: This paper analyzes some of the problems with error counting as well as the difficulty of proposing viable alternatives. Background: Counting and tabulating negatives (e.g., errors) are currently popular ways to measure and help improve safety in a variety of domains. They uphold an illusion of rationality and control but may offer neither real insight nor productive routes for improving safety. Method: The paper conducts a critical analysis of assumptions underlying error counting in human factors. Results: Error counting is a form of structural analysis that focuses on (supposed) causes and consequences; it defines risk and safety instrumentally in terms of minimizing negatives and their measurable effects. In this way, physicians can be proven to be 7500 times less safe than gun owners, as they are responsible for many more accidental deaths. Conclusion: The appeal of error counting may lie in a naive realism that can enchant researchers and practitioners alike. Supporting facts will continue to be found by those looking for errors through increasingly refined methods. Application: The paper outlines a different approach to understanding safety in complex systems that is more socially and politically oriented and that places emphasis on interpretation and social construction rather than on putatively objective structural features.
Peer Reviewed Yes
Published Yes
Alternative URI http://dx.doi.org/10.1518/001872007X312423
Volume 49
Issue Number 2
Page from 177
Page to 184
ISSN 0018-7208
Date Accessioned 2011-03-08
Date Available 2011-05-30T06:55:53Z
Language en_AU
Faculty Arts, Education and Law
Subject Environmental and Occupational Health and Safety
URI http://hdl.handle.net/10072/38860
Publication Type Journal Articles (Refereed Article)
Publication Type Code c1x

Show simple item record

Griffith University copyright notice