The Ethics of Terror Bombing: Beyond supreme emergency

There are no files associated with this record.

Title The Ethics of Terror Bombing: Beyond supreme emergency
Author Bellamy, Alex J.
Journal Name Journal of Military Ethics
Year Published 2008
Place of publication Norway
Publisher Taylor and Francis
Abstract Recent years have seen a revival of interest in Michael Walzer's doctrine of 'supreme emergency'. Simply put, the doctrine holds that, when a state confronts an opponent who threatens annihilation, it can be morally legitimate to violate one of the cardinal rules of the war convention - the principle of non-combatant immunity. Walzer cites the case of Britain's decision to bomb German cities in 1940 as a case in point. Although the theory of supreme emergency has been scrutinised, the historical case that Walzer refers to has not been looked at in depth. This article seeks to remedy this problem by asking whether the principle actors involved in the decision to bomb German cities understood themselves to be in a supreme emergency. It argues that the British leadership never openly admitted that they were in fact targeting German civilians, and that the principle reason for this was a widespread belief that the British and American publics would not support such a campaign. As a result, throughout the war, the British government publicly maintained the fiction that the devastation of German cities was a collateral product of attacks on its industrial infrastructure. This, in turn, suggests that liberal societies - even those facing imminent destruction - do not tend to support a relaxing of the rules of non-combatant immunity, suggesting that the prohibition on deliberately killing non-combatants may be more embedded than has hitherto been thought.
Peer Reviewed Yes
Published Yes
Alternative URI http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/15027570801953448
Volume 7
Issue Number 1
Page from 41
Page to 65
ISSN 1502-7589
Date Accessioned 2011-05-09
Date Available 2011-08-30T06:20:25Z
Language en_AU
Research Centre Centre for Governance and Public Policy; Griffith Asia Institute
Faculty Griffith Business School
Subject International Relations
URI http://hdl.handle.net/10072/40449
Publication Type Journal Articles (Refereed Article)
Publication Type Code c1x

Brief Record

Griffith University copyright notice