What a Difference a Rater Makes: Rater-Method Variance and Conscientiousness-Work Performance Correlations

There are no files associated with this record.

Title What a Difference a Rater Makes: Rater-Method Variance and Conscientiousness-Work Performance Correlations
Author Poropat, Arthur Eugene
Publication Title IOP 2011 : 9th Industrial and Organisational Psychology Conference: Connectivity in a dynamic world Human connection in a world of rapid change Conference Proceedings
Editor Nerina L. Jimmieson, Neal M. Ashkanasy and Lisa M. Bradley
Year Published 2011
Place of publication Brisbane, Australia
Publisher Australian Psychological Society
Abstract Conscientiousness has been demonstrated to reliably predict workplace performance, but previous research has relied almost exclusively on self-other correlational designs, which may inadvertently reduce observed correlations. However, these have been preferred because the main alternative, obtaining ratings of multiple measures from the same source, raises concerns about common-method variance and associated bias. To address these problems, a structural equation modeling analysis of meta-analytic, multitrait-multirater data was conducted to estimate construct-level correlations of conscientiousness with performance. Construct-level correlations were substantially greater than scalecorrected self-other correlations of conscientiousness with overall performance and citizenship performance. Despite substantial method variance, self-self correlations provided the most accurate estimates of construct-level correlations. Implications for understanding the relationship between conscientiousness and performance, especially citizenship performance, are discussed. Reviewers should reconsider what rating methods are appropriate for specific questions, and researchers should use a broader range of sources when estimating construct-level relationships.
Peer Reviewed Yes
Published Yes
Publisher URI http://www.iopconference.com.au/
ISBN 978-0-909881-50-4
Conference name IOP 2011 : 9th Industrial and Organisational Psychology Conference
Location Brisbane, Australia
Date From 2011-06-23
Date To 2011-06-26
URI http://hdl.handle.net/10072/40748
Date Accessioned 2011-09-07
Date Available 2011-09-09T07:06:17Z
Language en_AU
Research Centre Behavioural Basis of Health
Faculty Griffith Health Faculty
Subject Industrial and Organisational Psychology; Personality, Abilities and Assessment; Psychological Methodology, Design and Analysis
Publication Type Conference Publications (Full Written Paper - Refereed)
Publication Type Code e1

Brief Record

Griffith University copyright notice